Disclaimer: I received a free copy and access to the Members-only Facebook group. It was not dependent on me posting a review (positive or otherwise) and the opinions here are my own.
You’ve wanted to discuss Charlotte Mason’s works in an inclusive, accepting group. One where you felt comfortable sharing your own interpretations of Charlotte Mason’s words based on your own spiritual values. One where you didn’t have to wonder if you’d be asked to leave or simply blocked because you don’t share others’ religious beliefs.
That place now exists.
At A Charlotte Mason Plenary, owners Ruk Martin and Rachel Lebowitz are committed to providing everyone a safe place to discuss Charlotte Mason’s works.
Their first session, a study of Volume I: Home Education, started in early January but I’ve waited to write a review.
I wanted to see how the concept would play out.
How it works
They have several Plenary sessions scheduled for this year, and though I can’t speak to future ones, I can tell you how the book discussion is working.
First, you get a download of the volume that they’ve edited and formatted for easy reading and note-taking. Not only that, but it is annotated with definitions of obscure words, fun facts, and explained references.
Then there is a members-only Facebook group in which Ruk and Rachel lead a discussion of the material. The discussion has been lively, with viewpoints all over the spectrum. Members vary widely in their religious beliefs, and the conversation is kept respectful and inclusive. We are encouraged to discuss how we can reconcile Charlotte’s words to our own beliefs.
Sometimes this is easy.
Other times we wrestle with it.
Ruk and Rachel are admins at Charlotte Mason Secular Homeschoolers (disclaimer: I am a moderator there) and have led inclusive Charlotte Mason groups in their hometowns.
Though I haven’t participated as much as I’d like to, I’ve found the conversation at the Charlotte Mason Plenary welcoming and respectful.
I highly recommend The Plenary if you are looking for resources to help you apply Charlotte Mason’s method to your life without the dogma.